Real-world Plone Experiences
Matt Blair of Humaninet has published a lengthy review of their experiences with Plone 2.05 and Plone 2.1.2. It's a meaty nugget of real-world nonprofit-sector Plone experience.
Late spring must be NGO season for Plone. Following hot on the heels of Oxfam GB's very successful Ploneability Plone for NGOs mini-conference, Matt Blair, Humaninet's Chief Plonista, has written at length about his experiences implementing Plone as a collaboration tool for Humaninet's internal and external project teams.
There's a lot of great feedback in these documents, covering both the general usability of Plone, as well as features specific to intensive team collaboration.
Matt's also written a very practical guide to evaluating third party Products for Plone, which contains a ton of hard-won wisdom, a simple explanation of Humaninet's custom workflows (a great example of this powerful feature in a real-world situation), and some interesting thoughts about Plone's unsuitability for multi-author real-time collaborative document editing. (Which is a darn hard problem, I might add, which no open-source CMS solves very well. Yet.)
Matt's writeup deserves a much closer look than I've had time to give it, but one thought that occurs to me right off is this: a bunch of his needs and frustrations seem to revolve around's Plone lack of built-in document versioning and rollback. I'm surprised that he didn't give CMFEditions a whirl, which on the surface seems like it's exactly what he needs, and was sponsored in large part by a fellow NGO, Oxfam GB, who presumably are using it for similar use cases.
Matt's notes on Plone usability
While browsing around on Matt's site, I noticed that he has a very honest post about Plone's usability and accessibility for the average systems integrator. http://notes.elsewisemedia.com/2006/03/07/nosi-plone-usability/
Matt Blair
Do you know Matt Blair or how to contact him?
There is a lot of good documentation on their site. It's a real shame that 99% of the people who look for Plone documentation will never see their website :-(
I'd like to encourage Matt to move some of his documentation onto plone.org (with the proper attribution, of course) in order to widen the audience it appeals to. However, I can't find his contact details on the web site. Do you know him?
Martin